phototestcenter.com

review center 11 Lens reviews raw software gold Photo printers reviews gold

Adobe Photoshop Lightroom

continued

Work with Lightroom and there are many examples of real progress in making it easier to get your images just how you want them. Particularly good are the curves tool and the crop tool. Everyday, basic functions which Lightroom just does better. The crop tool probably got the biggest wow at the Adobe lecture - While the Photoshop version offers lots of controls and can do all you need, the Lightroom version is really clever. To start with there’s a simple tick box to choose - maintain aspect ratio - very useful, if you want to crop and straighten a whole pile of images but print them out the same shape - you don’t even have to select whether each image is upright or landscape - when you select the crop tool it starts full frame so is set correctly before you even begin. Then comes the really smart stuff - when you drag out the crop box it automatically stays within the image even if you rotate the mask, and if you do rotate, it also brings up a grid over the image to help you level the horizon etc and, rather than the mask rotating, as it does in Photoshop, with Lightroom the image rotates leaving the area you’ve selected upright in the center - again making it much easier to judge if you’ve got your image straight.  Wow.

Lightroom crop tool

The wonderful new crop tool in action - the grid appears as if by magic when you hold down the mouse button to drag the image round and then disappears when you’re finished so that you can see how well you’ve done. To help even more the cropped image is what stays straight - the original rotates. If you decide next week that you got it wrong and want to re-crop the image - no problem just click on the crop tool and you’re back to here - just before you cropped.

After adjusting your image in Develop you move on to output the results in either Slide Show, Print or Web. Each module offers a huge amount of control - This is great, but also one of Lightroom’s problems. There is just so much here - so many options in each module that while it’s aim is to simplify the process, it offers so many buttons and drop down panels that it ends up being just too complicated. Most images don’t need dozens of adjustments - If you’re a half decent photographer - and Lightroom is aimed at pros - you should only need a few little tweaks to each image before moving on. RawShooter managed that balance between having the tools you need easily accessible but keeping it simple, and was fast to use as a result, but Lightroom seems to miss the mark. In a word it is slow to use. Very slow. There are just so many choices to make, and it’s demand that you go through the import, catalogue, keywords routine every time you want to open an image really slows my work rate and raises by blood pressure. In time I’m sure I’ll get quicker, but for now I’m back to being a really slow worker again.

Of course there are parts of the process which are fast - cropping images is far faster than in Photoshop. With Lightroom if you straighten an image by cropping it, but don’t quite get it right first time, you don’t have to start the process again, you just click the crop tool and there is your cropping box just before you double clicked - adjust it and try again. It’s bliss. In fact the whole idea of storing adjustments as instruction sets rather than finished TIFs or JPEGs is that you can do this with any change you’ve made, they’re all still there just as you left them. That is great.

Like many photographers I like to print my pictures with a wide white border and put a thin black stroke around the image - This is something that I’ve always used Adobe Photoshop for, but I was surprised to find that the Print module in Lightroom can do all of that - in fact one of the “ooh” moments at the Adobe lecture was when it was explained to us that Lightroom does a far better job of this than Photoshop CS2, as it takes account of printer margins and resizes the image if necessary so that you never get only one border, or part borders, only what you intended, regardless of the stroke width. No more weird half or quarter borders !! That really would be excellent - So far all I’ve had from Lightroom are perfect borders.

Lightroom print screen

The Lightroom print screen - it’s all very simple and the slider at the top right for stroke width makes adding a border much easier and more predictable. With multiple images the image width remains constant - which is exactly what I would choose to happen - and landscape images are rotated to fit.

Next Page

review center 11 Lens reviews raw software gold Photo printers reviews gold
[Home] [Review Center] [RAW Software Reviews] [RAW File Test Index] [Adobe Lightroom Review] [Adobe Lightroom p2] [Adobe Lightroom p3] [RAW Software Reviews] [Lens Tests] [Photo Printer Reviews] [About Phototestcenter] [About the Author]

All text and images copyright David Gold 2006 - 2008
and must not be reproduced in any way without permission
davidgold@ezeedsl.co.uk

>